1 - What PayPal says
PP-R-YDB-10198967
WAITING_FOR_SELLER_RESPONSECHARGEBACK
PayPal wants:
PROOF_OF_FULFILLMENTPROOF_OF_REFUNDOTHER
Actions PayPal offers now:
accept_claimprovide_evidence
Risk: card chargeback (external channel): the card network, not PayPal, makes the final call
PayPal API calls (debug ids)dispute PP-R-YDB-10198967 debug_id=f461392374998
capture 259670644T221515B debug_id=f5042354207e9
order 0RU79894XT690480D debug_id=f6974482d4b8a
tracker 259670644T221515B-9400111202555842761299 lookup failed: GET /v1/shipping/trackers/259670644T221515B-9400111202555842761299 -> HTTP 403 [] debug_id=f6974487f1e55
2 - Evidence from PayPal and the shop
E1 Order JT-SBX-095612-not-as-des placed 2026-11-11 for USD 58.00
answers: PROOF_OF_RECEIPT_COPY, OTHER
E2 Tracking 9400111202555842761299 status SHIPPED (tracking on file at PayPal)
answers: PROOF_OF_FULFILLMENT
E3 Listing TEA-CHAI-300 as published: Masala chai blend, 300 g
answers: ITEM_DESCRIPTION, OTHER
Green = answers what PayPal asked for. Coverage 67%.
3 - Approve, file, verify
FIGHT
records cover 2/3 requested evidence types: PROOF_OF_FULFILLMENT, OTHER
approval token 268a013e99d6 = hash of the exact call. enter the judge password first
Notes (writer: LLM, repaired after verifier feedback)
The order with invoice JT-SBX-095612-not-as-des was placed on 2026-11-11 for USD 58.00 E1. The purchased item was SKU TEA-CHAI-300, listed as “Masala chai blend, 300 g” E3. The shipment was dispatched with tracking number 9400111202555842761299 and the carrier status shows SHIPPED E2. The tracking information was provided to PayPal as proof of fulfillment E2.
Verifier: every fact traced to cited evidence
Draft rejected by the verifierV8 delivery claim without a delivery record: 'The item delivered matches the product description provided '
Exact PayPal call
{
"method": "provide_evidence",
"args": [
"PP-R-YDB-10198967",
{
"evidences": [
{
"evidence_type": "PROOF_OF_FULFILLMENT",
"notes": "The order with invoice JT-SBX-095612-not-as-des was placed on 2026-11-11 for USD 58.00 [E1]. The purchased item was SKU TEA-CHAI-300, listed as “Masala chai blend, 300 g” [E3]. The shipment was dispatched with tracking number 9400111202555842761299 and the carrier status shows SHIPPED [E2]. The tracking information was provided to PayPal as proof of fulfillment [E2]."
}
],
"also_answers": [
"OTHER"
]
}
]
}